This loop set out to check our instruments on the borides behind our cobalt-free lead, Mn₂FeB₂, using the two compounds of that structure type that have actually been made. It then built new compositions in the same type.
New candidate: Mn₄FeCoB₄. It is on the measured rung: every criterion of the objective has a measurement inside its target, while stability in one PBE setup, a measured anisotropy anywhere in the type, and whether it can be made are still open. On its lowest arrangement it reads 1.21–1.25 MJ/m³ along c at 1.43 T, with a Curie point near 480–500 K after calibration, for 6.66 $/kg. That is behind Mn₂FeB₂ on anisotropy (1.74–1.84 MJ/m³ at 1.49 T) and slightly better on the hull. Unlike Mn₂FeB₂, which is an existing database entry, it is a composition no database or paper holds.
The made MoMn₂B₂ and WMn₂B₂ (Curie points 400 K and 380 K) gave the type its first calibration. Our Curie route reads them 1.42–1.47× high, so Mn₂FeB₂'s Curie point is about 560–580 K, comfortably above our 450 K line rather than borderline. On anisotropy, nobody has measured one in this type. The only check available is a published DFT number for WMn₂B₂, which agrees with ours on the sign (easy plane) but is a ninth of our size, and our three methods agree with each other on that number. The type behaves consistently on our route: the atom on the small metal site sets the sign. Iron and iron–cobalt give an easy axis along c; molybdenum and tungsten give an easy plane. Iron with nickel loses most of the anisotropy.
PBE, DZP basis, kspacing 0.2 Å⁻¹, each cell relaxed in DFT and measured on its own relaxed cell; K is along c against the plane (positive means easy axis), and the in-plane directions agreed within 0.01 MJ/m³ in every cell. Curie points are the route's Monte Carlo value; the type's made members put the route 1.42–1.47× high. Hull distances are on the Orb surface.
Cell | Geometry | Novelty | K along c (MJ/m³) | Js (T) | Curie route (K) | Orb hull (meV/atom) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
MoMn₂B₂ (calibration) | ||||||
WMn₂B₂ (calibration) | ||||||
The targets are K ≥ 1 MJ/m³ along one axis, Js ≥ 1 T, a Curie point of 450 K or more, and at most 75 meV/atom above the hull. The Mn₂FeB₂ value is our stricter method (force theorem); its earlier reading was +1.84. The WMn₂B₂ value is the total-energy reference, which agrees within 4 % with our two faster methods. On published-PBE references, Mn₄FeCoB₄ sits 36.8 meV/atom above the hull against 40.3 for Mn₂FeB₂, and the two Mn₄FeCoB₄ arrangements are within 1.6 meV/atom of each other in DFT. That makes it a solid solution of iron and cobalt on that site, and the reading of 1.05–1.25 MJ/m³ belongs to the composition. Mn₄FeCoB₄ has no imaginary phonon mode (run), costs 6.66 $/kg, and matches nothing in Materials Project, Alexandria, GNoME or COD (run
Mn₄FeCoB₄ as relaxed. Manganese pairs sit on the large site between boron dimers, and iron and cobalt alternate along the chains on the small site, which run along the easy axis c:
Our anisotropy route agrees in sign with published DFT in this type: partly. WMn₂B₂ is easy-plane by every method we have (predicted −1.3 to −0.3, read −7.5); MoMn₂B₂ −0.61 sits in its range. The size is nine times the published number, and the cause is unknown.
The Curie route reads the made members 1.3–2.2× high: held. 1.47× and 1.42×.
Fe beside Co or Ni on the small site keeps ≥ 1.2 MJ/m³ at ≥ 1.3 T: held for cobalt, refuted for nickel. Mn₄FeCoB₄ 1.21–1.25 at 1.43 T; Mn₄FeNiB₄ 0.60 at 1.23 T, below both of its parents.
Mn₂FeB₂'s Curie point is no longer borderline: on its own structure type's calibration it is about 560–580 K.
The type has a consistent rule on our route: a late 3d atom on the small site gives an easy axis, a 4d or 5d atom an easy plane. Iron and cobalt mix there almost freely and keep the axis; iron and nickel do not.
There is still no measured anisotropy anywhere in this structure type. Every anisotropy number here, ours and the published one, is computed.
Mn₄FeCoB₄ is not a validated magnet. Its stability rests on the Orb surface and on published-PBE references scored by Orb. Our own PBE check cannot yet run in this chemistry, because Mn₂B converges to the wrong magnetic state in our setup. Its anisotropy is in the DZP basis, in a type where no measurement exists to check it against. Nobody has made it or the iron–cobalt solid solution it belongs to. A same-setup stability check built without Mn₂B would be the cheapest thing that could overturn it.
Earlier: loop 54
made |
0.881 |
587 (400 measured) |
made |
0.865 |
540 (380 measured) |
computed-only (Alexandria) |
1.489 |
new composition |
1.434 |
new composition |
1.438 |
not checked |
1.226 |
Cell + ionic relaxation with ABACUS DFT; 0.04 eV/Å threshold; final energy = -39490.0973 eV; energy change = -0.0353 eV
The made MoMn₂B₂ and WMn₂B₂ calibrate the Curie route (1.42–1.47×) and check the anisotropy route's sign; a new composition, Mn₄FeCoB₄, reaches the measured rung beside Mn₂FeB₂.