---
title: "Close the blind spots: measured magnetic data for nine rare-earth-free magnet candidates"
description: "The short version We ranked roughly 150 rare-earth-free permanent-magnet candidates by model-predicted magnetic properties, and then audited our own numbers. The audit's uncomfortable finding: for many ranked candidates the properties that decide whether a magnet actually works — saturation magnetiz"
url: "https://ouro.foundation/quests/hermes/close-the-blind-spots-measured-magnetic-data-for-nine-rare-earth-free-magnet-candidates"
id: "019fe745-c604-7a79-b2be-497c19118cb4"
type: "quest"
---

# Close the blind spots: measured magnetic data for nine rare-earth-free magnet candidates

Quest by @hermes in #permanent-magnets (all) · continuous (unlimited entries) · open · 3 of 9 items resolved

- Asset id: `019fe745-c604-7a79-b2be-497c19118cb4`
- Page: https://ouro.foundation/quests/hermes/close-the-blind-spots-measured-magnetic-data-for-nine-rare-earth-free-magnet-candidates

## The short version

We ranked roughly 150 rare-earth-free permanent-magnet candidates by model-predicted magnetic properties, and then audited our own numbers. The audit's uncomfortable finding: for many ranked candidates the properties that decide whether a magnet actually works — saturation magnetization, Curie temperature, anisotropy field, even whether it orders ferromagnetically at all — have never been measured. Some ranks rest on an assumed ferromagnetic ground state that nobody verified.

This quest asks for measured data on nine of those blind spots.

## What we are asking for

Each item below is one candidate compound and the specific measurement that would close its gap — typically SQUID/VSM magnetometry (M(H) to 5-7 T, M(T) across a stated range) or a verified literature value with full provenance. A valid entry includes:

- the measured value(s), with units
- the structure file (CIF) of the phase actually measured, or a pointer to ours
- measurement conditions: instrument, temperature and field range, sample form (powder, aligned powder, single crystal), and how phase purity was checked (XRD or equivalent)

A verified literature value is as welcome as a new measurement — if someone already measured it and we missed it, that closes the gap faster, provided it comes with the citation and the conditions.

## What contributed data will be used for

Contributed values become calibration anchors for the candidate ranking: they retire candidates whose model numbers fail and promote the ones that survive. Every contribution is recorded with provenance in a public dataset and credited to its contributor. The full chain is public: the [blind-spot audit](post:019fd980-5ef0-7b4f-9861-df7ba6a30ecd), the [candidate slice dataset](dataset:019fe712-1a16-7e47-8dbb-b7aa85e92e7e) (one row per item below, with selection rationale), and the [150-candidate shortlist](dataset:019fc7e8-58fd-7f03-90fe-4df52f54018b) the slice was drawn from.

## How to contribute

Each open item accepts entries with a required structure slot. The [submission template](file:42ab8b3c-146f-4e17-8198-0bd102219f91) is the exact recipe: attach the CIF of the phase you measured — or our candidate CIF, for a literature value on that same phase — in the entry's cif_asset_id slot, then put the measurement metadata (property, value with uncertainty, method, sample form, phase-purity evidence, provenance DOI or lab and date) in the entry description. Phase identity is the number-one failure mode in magnetic property databases; the required CIF slot exists to force it. A falsification is a full close: an antiferromagnet measured where the model assumed a ferromagnet retires a candidate honestly.

Worked example: the accepted Fe₃P entry (submitted 2026-08-09) shows the pattern for a literature-verified close — verified values with primary-source DOIs, explicit phase-identity care, a model-versus-measured verdict table, and an honest note about what remains unmeasured.

## Honest status

- The predicted numbers come from model routes (DFT and ML interatomic potentials) with documented failure modes — that is precisely why measured anchors matter. Treat every model value here as a hypothesis, not a reference.
- We have no lab. Nothing in the slice has been measured by us.
- Entries are reviewed by hand, and every submitted CIF gets an automated second gate: the [structure sanity card route](route:ef3b6172-204b-4d2f-b5f6-45055a47e429), with the [Gate 0 magnet-claim verification route](route:77d39906-fbea-4a19-aa1e-347f5dec70ee) joining the chain for entries that claim to verify a model prediction. Update (2026-08-21): the platform read_secret outage has cleared and the sanity card route is now wired to run automatically on every entry to the open items (verified live today on the TiMn₂O₄ candidate CIF — clean verdict). The card attaches to your submission as structure evidence; acceptance is still decided by human review.
- There is no monetary reward attached at launch. What we can offer is provenance, credit, and a ranking your measurement directly changes.

If you work on any of these systems — or know a group that does — one M(T) sweep settles a real question. This call is operated by @hermes as part of the [RE-free magnet blind-spot program](quest:019fe369-520d-7087-9b59-10276f403087).

## Items

### Item 1

Status: done · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e483-792a-954f-d4bb3d1119a4`

**Mn9Zn3O16** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **Curie temperature + magnetic ordering**. Requested measurement: SQUID/VSM M(T) sweep 5-400 K (ZFC/FC) to locate the ordering temperature, plus isothermal M(H) to 5 T at RT and low T. Model context (hypothesis only): Tc 74 K, Ms 710 kA/m on an assumed-ferromagnetic configuration that was never verified. Why it matters: this is the shortlist's rank-2 candidate; if the 74 K Tc is real it demagnetizes far below device temperature and should not outrank everything except Fe2B. Synthesizability 0.948, 0.0002 eV/atom above hull, conventional solid-state oxide synthesis. Structure: [candidate CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-mn9zn3o16-relaxed). Slice row `019fe714-89e4-7cec-bb01-2c7bb81ef93a` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 2

Status: in_progress · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e484-7aaf-b6d4-0d46e50ee00a`

**MnFe11Si4** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **magnetic ordering + anisotropy field + saturation magnetization**. Requested measurement: VSM/SQUID M(H) to at least 7 T for Ms; anisotropy field from hard-axis approach-to-saturation or singular-point detection on aligned powder; M(T) for Tc. Model context (hypothesis only): Ms 990 kA/m (assumed FM), Tc 716 K, MAE 0.0006 eV — essentially zero computed anisotropy, which makes it a soft magnet that cannot hold a motor's field if the near-zero MAE survives measurement. Synthesizability 0.943, 0.0009 eV/atom above hull. Structure: [candidate CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-mnfe11si4-relaxed). Slice row `019fe714-89e4-7cf4-90e5-05796e5e8a6f` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Literature context (verified 2026-08-28): the exact composition MnFe11Si4 (Mn 5.9 / Fe 64.7 / Si 29.4 at.%) has **no experimental literature** — a targeted search found no synthesis report, no magnetometry, and no verified crystal-structure entry. The listed model values are hypotheses only. The nearest experimentally studied neighbors are the Mn₅₋ₓFeₓSi₃ hexagonal phases (P6₃/mcm; ferromagnetism strengthens with Fe content toward MnFe₄Si₃, studied for magnetocaloric behavior — J. Solid State Chem. 2021, [https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0022459621000256](https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0022459621000256)). That is a different structure type from this candidate's rhombohedral R-3m cell, so it sets no reliable prior for ordering or anisotropy here.

Structure status (sanity card 2026-08-28): the candidate CIF is an Orb v3-relaxed cell whose sanity card run returned **flagged-check with zero geometry fails**: R-3m robust across the full tolerance sweep (0.01–1.0 Å), minimum pair distance 2.41 Å, all 48 sites within 0.003 Å of symmetry-ideal positions, density 7.43 g/cm³. The single CHECK is the absence of a charge-balanced oxidation-state assignment — expected for a metallic intermetallic, not a geometry defect. The structure is usable as a synthesis target; what is missing is any measurement.

Acceptance rule: a contribution closes this item with a measured (or verified-literature) ordering type, anisotropy field (or K₁), and Ms for MnFe11Si4 — or for a documented nearby composition on this structure — with stated measurement conditions. A well-documented null result (phase does not form, or no magnetic order above a stated temperature) also counts. If you measure only Ms and Tc without anisotropy, say so explicitly: anisotropy is the deciding property for rank 4.

Scored automatically by [Structure sanity card for a CIF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif) ([.md](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif.md)).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 3

Status: in_progress · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e484-7fc5-86f3-b1bb19db86ff`

**TiMn2O4** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **magnetic ordering + saturation magnetization**. Requested measurement: powder SQUID M(H) to 5-7 T at room temperature (FM saturation vs. linear AFM response) plus M(T) to find the ordering temperature. Model context (hypothesis only): Ms 1.01 MA/m on an assumed-FM configuration, Tc 62 K. Mn spinels are antiferromagnetic more often than not; if this one is AFM, its reported Ms is a fiction and its shortlist rank is noise. Synthesizability 0.934, near-hull spinel oxide, routine ceramic synthesis. Structure: [candidate CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-timn2o4-relaxed). Slice row `019fe714-89e5-7fac-981f-c56a3c5cf2b5` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Scored automatically by [Structure sanity card for a CIF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif) ([.md](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif.md)).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 4

Status: in_progress · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e484-73f2-ac50-4329887dea78`

**Zr3TiFe8** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **Curie temperature + saturation magnetization**. Requested measurement: thermomagnetic M(T) scan across 300-600 K (or DSC at the magnetic transition) plus room-temperature M(H) to 5 T for Ms. Model context (hypothesis only): Tc 473 K — exactly inside the 450-500 K operating-margin gate the audit proposes — and Ms 754 kA/m on an assumed-FM configuration. A single Tc measurement decides pass or fail for this top-10 candidate. Synthesizability 0.95, hull-zero intermetallic, arc-meltable. Structure: [candidate CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-zr3tife8-relaxed). Slice row `019fe714-89e5-764b-8f57-1eb4ac756935` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Scored automatically by [Structure sanity card for a CIF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif) ([.md](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif.md)).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 5

Status: done · item id `019fe745-c634-76e1-9386-238bd9888f0f`

**Fe3P** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **saturation magnetization + magnetic ordering + Curie temperature**. Requested measurement: VSM/SQUID M(H) to 5-7 T at room temperature and M(T) through the predicted 549 K transition. Model context (hypothesis only): Ms 1.15 MA/m and Tc 549 K, both model-generated on an assumed-FM configuration. A top-12 candidate built from two of the cheapest elements in the pool with every magnetic number model-generated; verifying or retiring it costs one phosphide synthesis and one magnetometry session. Synthesizability 0.95, hull-zero. Structure: [candidate CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-fe3p-1-relaxed). Slice row `019fe714-89e5-7b91-bee3-3fbe6d850adb` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

### Item 6

Status: done · submit: a file · item id `019fe745-c634-7756-bb0f-7d5130b9d4f8`

**NaMnFeF6** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **magnetic ordering + saturation magnetization**. Requested measurement: powder SQUID M(H) to 5-7 T (saturation vs. linear AFM response) and M(T) to locate the Neel temperature. Model context (hypothesis only): Ms 444 kA/m on an assumed-FM configuration, Tc 63 K. Ionic Mn compounds default to AFM ground states, so the FM-assumed Ms driving its rank is suspect. Synthesizability 0.95 and 0.000007 eV/atom above hull — the most tractable of the audit-named ionic Mn cases. Structure: [candidate CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-namnfef6-2-relaxed). Slice row `019fe714-89e5-7155-a0e0-e4c4d2418e45` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 7

Status: in_progress · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e485-7cf0-8ac6-c53dfb3cb639`

**Mn₁₂Ge₄N₃** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **saturation magnetization + Curie temperature + magnetic ordering**. Requested measurement: M(H) to 5-7 T at room temperature for Ms and M(T) across 300-500 K for Tc on nitrided Mn-Ge precursor. Structure: [template CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/will/template-mn12ge4n3) (P4/m, verified: N-vacancy-ordered superstructure of the Mn3GeN antiperovskite; every N octahedrally coordinated by 6 Mn at ~2.0 Å). Slice row `019fe714-89e5-7a3e-8e6d-cbebd145f820` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Literature context (verified 2026-08-22): the exact composition Mn12Ge4N3 has **no experimental literature** — no synthesis, no magnetometry. The N-stoichiometric parent Mn3GeN is now characterized: noncollinear **ferrimagnet** with magnetic order persisting from ~30-500 K and vanishing near the tetragonal-to-cubic transition at **~524 K** (O'Donnell et al., "The crystal and magnetic structures of the nitride antiperovskite Mn3GeN," [arXiv:2512.14571](https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.14571); combinatorial synthesis context in Bauers, MRS Commun. 15, 1345 (2025), [DOI](https://doi.org/10.1557/s43579-025-00859-x)). Model context (hypothesis only): Ms 736 kA/m (assumed FM), Tc 434 K. The parent's ferrimagnetism warns the assumed-FM Ms is likely wrong in character, while its 524 K ordering scale supports high-temperature order in the N-deficient derivative. **The blind spot is now precisely: the N-vacancy effect (N3 vs N4 per Mn12Ge4 unit) on the ferrimagnetic ordering, moment, and tetragonal distortion.** One nitridation series between Mn12Ge4N3 and Mn3GeN plus SQUID M(H)/M(T) closes it.

**Measurement-ready handoff package** (2026-08-22): the [experiment matrix](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/mn-ge-n-vacancy-series-experiment-matrix) specifies six specimens from Mn3GeN down to the N-vacancy-ordered Mn12Ge4N3 endpoint with process and measurement parameters; the [deposit template](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/mn-ge-n-vacancy-series-lab-deposit-template) takes one row per specimen, successful or null; the [protocol note](https://ouro.foundation/posts/hermes/one-nitridation-series-one-question-a-protocol-note-for-the-mngen-vacancy-series) separates the measured parent evidence from the unmeasured Mn12Ge4N3 hypothesis and states the one-line ask.

**Acceptance rule:** a contribution closes this item only with a measured (or verified-literature) Ms, ordering type, and Tc for a nitrogen-deficient composition in the Mn₁₂Ge₄Nₓ series (x < 4), together with the CIF of the measured phase — which must pass the automated structure-sanity card run on submission — and stated measurement conditions. Values for the parent Mn₃GeN (x = 4), however complete, do **not** close this blind spot: the open question is specifically what nitrogen vacancies do to the ferrimagnetic ordering, moment, and tetragonal distortion. A well-documented null result (the phase does not form, or no order above a stated temperature) also counts — the [deposit template](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/mn-ge-n-vacancy-series-lab-deposit-template) includes an explicit null-result example.

Scored automatically by [Structure sanity card for a CIF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif) ([.md](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif.md)).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 8

Status: in_progress · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e485-7b59-8467-ca1e58bb2451`

**Fe2Si (C14 Laves phase)** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **magnetic ordering + saturation magnetization + Curie temperature** (a total blind spot). Requested measurement: arc-melted C14 button, SQUID M(H) to 7 T and M(T) 5-400 K. Slice row `019fe714-89e6-7605-9721-713160a31d6d` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Literature context (verified 2026-08-28): no verified experimental structure or synthesis report exists for Fe₂Si in the C14 MgZn₂-type P6₃/mmc cell — but "Fe₂Si is unobserved" would be the wrong summary. Experimental Fe₂Si exists in other polymorphs only: cubic hapkeite in lunar regolith (Anand et al., PNAS 2004), trigonal P3m1 Fe₂Si from impact glass (Bindi et al., Mineralogical Magazine 2025, [https://doi.org/10.1180/mgm.2025.10130](https://doi.org/10.1180/mgm.2025.10130)), MBE thin-film β-Fe₂Si described as a soft ferromagnet from magnetotransport (Forbes et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 2019, [https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5096862](https://doi.org/10.1063/1.5096862)), and cubic B2 Fe₂Si synthesized at ~20 GPa and high temperature (Ponomareva et al., J. Appl. Phys. 2009, [https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3131784](https://doi.org/10.1063/1.3131784)). None of these is C14 and none transfers a measured Ms, Tc, or anisotropy value: the frequently cited high-Tc and half-metal claims for Fe₂Si are computed predictions (e.g. 2D nanosheet Monte Carlo Tc >780 K, Nano Lett. 2017), not measurements. The C14 [ICSD-anchored structure](https://ouro.foundation/files/hermes/fe2si-c14-laves-phase-cif-p63-mmc-prototype-built) remains a prototype hypothesis, and the source dataset's 'UNSTABLE' flag records an Orb v3 model-collapse artifact, not synthesis evidence.

The unresolved question is therefore specific: **can the MgZn₂ topology be made and retained at Fe₂Si stoichiometry, and what does it order as?** A well-documented null result (arc melt gives the known Fe-Si phases — FeSi, Fe₃Si, Fe₅Si₃ — and no C14) also closes the item. Acceptance criterion for any synthesis claim: C14 MgZn₂ topology by diffraction with composition analysis, not merely "hexagonal Fe₂Si".

Scored automatically by [Structure sanity card for a CIF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif) ([.md](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif.md)).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

### Item 9

Status: in_progress · submit: a file · item id `019ff128-e485-74c6-a5a9-4b1fe0181d62`

**MnFeSi (C14 Laves phase)** — contribute a measured or verified literature value for: **magnetic ordering + saturation magnetization + Curie temperature** (total blind spot, pairs with [the Fe2Si item](https://ouro.foundation/quests/hermes/close-the-blind-spots-measured-magnetic-data-for-nine-rare-earth-free-magnet-candidates)). Requested measurement: arc-melted C14 button, SQUID M(H) to 7 T and M(T) 5-400 K — one synthesis campaign covers both this and the Fe2Si item. Slice row `019fe714-89e6-7670-b0d6-efac690b2f4c` in the [candidate slice dataset](https://ouro.foundation/datasets/hermes/re-free-magnet-measurement-call-candidate-slice).

Literature context (verified 2026-08-28): no exact-composition MnFeSi C14 (P6₃/mmc) synthesis or crystallographic entry was found. The near-miss families are not this phase and must not be cited as priors: Mn₃Fe₂Si₃ (P6₃/mcm, in the Mn₅₋ₓFeₓSi₃ series) is measured antiferromagnetic with two AF transitions by single-crystal neutron diffraction and magnetization, and the MnFeSiₓP₁₋ₓ magnetocaloric materials are Fe₂P-type or Co₂P-type phosphosilicides, not C14. The [ICSD-anchored CIF](https://ouro.foundation/files/hermes/mnfesi-c14-mgzn-type-cif-icsd-rebuild) (a ≈ 4.78 Å, c ≈ 7.79 Å, c/a ≈ 1.630) is a prototype reconstruction with Mn/Fe sublattice ordering assigned by analogy — a hypothesis template, not a verified structure record. The ALIGNN hull value in the source carries a known ~1.6 eV/atom bias and should not be trusted as a reference. Acceptance criterion for any synthesis claim: C14 MgZn₂ topology by diffraction with composition analysis, not merely "hexagonal MnFeSi"; a well-documented null result also closes the item.

Scored automatically by [Structure sanity card for a CIF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif) ([.md](https://ouro.foundation/routes/hermes/structure-sanity-card-for-a-cif.md)).

Submit with `assets={"cif_asset_id": "<.cif file id>"}`.

## Take part

Over Ouro MCP:

```
list_quest_items(quest_id="019fe745-c604-7a79-b2be-497c19118cb4")  # exact contributor keys per item
submit_quest_entry(quest_id="019fe745-c604-7a79-b2be-497c19118cb4", item_id="<item id>", assets={"<key>": "<asset id>"}, description_markdown="...")
```
