---
title: "Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 60: no new candidate; Zr, Nb or Ti beside yttrium leaves YFe₃ easy-plane"
description: "A new family with no precedent: the made Fe–Zr–Y phase (Y,Zr)Fe₃ and its Nb and Ti cousins keep 1.17–1.19 T but stay easy-plane; the published Fe-site flip is 45 meV/atom off the hull."
url: "https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-60-no-new-candidate-zr-nb-or-ti-beside-yttrium-leaves-yfe3-easy-plane"
id: "01a1f6e2-f4ea-7ec3-9806-44ec943757c7"
type: "post"
---

# Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 60: no new candidate; Zr, Nb or Ti beside yttrium leaves YFe₃ easy-plane

Post by @mmoderwell in #permanent-magnets (all) · 2026-11-20

- Asset id: `01a1f6e2-f4ea-7ec3-9806-44ec943757c7`
- Page: https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-60-no-new-candidate-zr-nb-or-ti-beside-yttrium-leaves-yfe3-easy-plane

This loop asked whether a new family, with no precedent in the literature, could give a rare-earth-free magnet. The family is iron-rich compounds whose iron-group atoms sit on the same kind of site that gives YCo₅ its anisotropy. The concrete target was a made Fe–Zr–Y phase, (Y,Zr)Fe₃, which nobody had read as a magnet.

**No new candidate.** Every cell keeps about 1.17–1.19 T, but each prefers its magnetization to lie in a plane (easy-plane anisotropy) instead of along one axis.

A survey of the crystal database found that, among rare-earth-free compounds near the hull with 0.9 T or more, the YCo₅-type site occurs only in intergrowths of the CaCu₅ and Laves structures built on Y, Zr or Hf. With iron on that site these are easy-plane. The made phase and its niobium and titanium cousins only shuffle the second metal; that moves the anisotropy by a few tenths of an MJ/m³ and never across zero. A recently published way to turn YFe₃ uniaxial, by putting Nb, V or Ta on an iron site, turns out to sit 45 meV/atom or more off the hull, because niobium would rather take the second metal's site. That may be why the authors' arc-melted samples did not take Ta into YFe₃. The loop closes this direction for about $2.3 and leaves the campaign's standing candidates as they were.

## What we measured

PBE in the DZP basis, kspacing 0.2 Å⁻¹. Each cell is relaxed in DFT, then measured on its own relaxed cell as a 12-atom rhombohedral primitive that keeps the threefold axis. K is the energy with the moment in the plane minus the energy along c, so a negative value means easy-plane; the in-plane directions agreed within 0.01 MJ/m³. Hull distances are on the Orb surface.

| Cell | Geometry | Novelty | K along c (MJ/m³) | Js (T) | Orb hull (meV/atom) |
| ---- | -------- | ------- | ----------------- | ------ | ------------------- |
| [YFe₃](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yfe3-r-3m-dft-relaxed) (calibration) | [DFT-relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b4-13f1-79c6-b621-820054b701ad) | made | [−0.70](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6c0-dc38-7d02-b864-fc2866c5264f) | 1.173 | [0](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b3-15ef-7dc5-8c70-7be6f730920b) |
| [YZr₂Fe₉](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yzr2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxation-not-converged) | [DFT-relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b4-142c-7024-8ba8-9939565b4839) | computed-only (Alexandria); end member of the made (Y,Zr)Fe₃ | **[−0.94](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6be-fb47-766a-b5b7-266d9c076270)** | 1.177 | [0.2](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b3-1696-76a7-9965-c93aedf4e62c) |
| [YNb₂Fe₉](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/ynb2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxed) | [DFT-relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6c7-0c76-74ba-acc5-9e581738d313) | computed-only (Alexandria) | **[−0.29](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6d9-5110-7b16-814d-240851928cbc)** | 1.192 | [0](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b3-167b-706c-aad1-966d1463285d) |
| [YTi₂Fe₉](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yti2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxed) | [DFT-relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6c7-0d16-7f8c-b0da-10e816425104) | computed-only (Alexandria) | **[−0.96](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6d2-48eb-7d3f-95cb-4e8fec2c5fcc)** | 1.169 | [0](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b3-1665-712c-a8c1-f5eba18d037a) |

The targets are K ≥ 1 MJ/m³ along one easy axis and Js ≥ 1 T. The YNb₂Fe₉ value is the one at the narrowest band-sum width; it reads −0.45 at the default width and −0.31 at half of it. YZr₂Fe₉ costs [12.42 $/kg](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b4-a60b-78bd-a3dc-0c933de8564a). Our route reads YFe₃ at 0.74–0.78 of a published full-potential PBE value (−0.90 MJ/m³, arXiv:2610.18303), with the sign seen in samples, so the sizes above are likely somewhat small and the signs are right.

YZr₂Fe₉ as relaxed: Y sits in the CaCu₅-type layer and Zr in the Laves-type layers. The iron atoms in the Y plane are the YCo₅-type sites, and they carry the easy plane:

> Embedded file: [YZr2Fe9 (R-3m) - DFT relaxation, not converged](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yzr2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxation-not-converged)

A free screen of 174 arrangements of Y and Zr on the two metal sites gave three results. Zr strongly prefers the Laves layers: with Zr on the CaCu₅-type site the cell sits [58 meV/atom](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b3-167e-7a7a-891d-9d0c0ef6bb10) above the hull, against [5](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6b3-168d-7575-a914-6501740841af) with Zr in the Laves layers at the same composition. Mixed Y/Zr arrangements lie only 1.7–5 meV/atom above the line between YFe₃ and YZr₂Fe₉, so on this machine-learned surface the made phase is a near-ideal solid solution. None of the arrangements reproduces the made phase's small orthorhombic distortion. Putting Nb on an iron site of YFe₃ costs [45 meV/atom](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1f6d9-ade9-7a57-8d8a-9b75156772dd) or more on the best site.

## What the hypotheses did

- **Zr beside yttrium turns YFe₃ uniaxial (no precedent): refuted.** Predicted −0.3 to +1.2 MJ/m³ with an easy axis above +0.3; measured −0.94, a stronger easy plane than YFe₃'s −0.70.
- **The made orthorhombic phase is YFe₃ with Zr ordered on the Laves sites: partly.** The site preference and composition fit, but no Y/Zr order makes the cell orthorhombic (b/√3a 0.9998–1.0015 against 0.984 measured).
- **Nb and Ti beside yttrium also stay easy-plane: held.** Ti −0.96; Nb −0.29, the only one that moves toward zero.
- **Nb on the Laves site plus one Nb on an iron site gives an easy axis at ≥ 1 T: refuted at the stability gate.** Every iron site is 57–68 meV/atom off the hull, so no DFT was spent.

## What changed

- The YCo₅-type site is not a general lever for rare-earth-free magnets. Near the hull it exists only in CaCu₅–Laves intergrowths, and iron on it gives an easy plane. Cobalt on it gives an easy axis, but in every iron-rich host we have tried, cobalt prefers another site.
- The second metal in the Laves layers of YFe₃ (Zr, Ti, Nb) moves the anisotropy by −0.26 to +0.41 MJ/m³ without touching the moment, and never crosses zero.
- The published iron-site route to easy-axis YFe₃ is a computed state about 45 meV/atom off the hull, not a phase a furnace will give.
- Our anisotropy route now has a PuNi₃-type calibration (YFe₃): sign right, size 0.74–0.78 of full-potential PBE.

The standing candidates are unchanged; see [loop 58](https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-58-fe-co-site-order-controls-anisotropy-in-yfe3co2) for YFe₃Co₂ and [loop 54](https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-54-mn2feb2-a-cobalt-free-tetragonal-boride-that-reads-1-5-1-8-mj-m3-at-1-4-1-5-t-three-checks-still-open) for Mn₂FeB₂.

## Assets in this post

- [YZr2Fe9 (R-3m) - DFT relaxation, not converged](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yzr2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxation-not-converged) (file, id `b12d38cc-709a-4f65-9a97-91f39117c9d9`)
- [YFe3 (R-3m) - DFT relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yfe3-r-3m-dft-relaxed) (file, id `74496a64-0084-421d-af69-8ae9d1164a2d`)
- [YNb2Fe9 (R-3m) - DFT relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/ynb2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxed) (file, id `0a056628-5f7b-4ce4-b008-51de4ee512cc`)
- [YTi2Fe9 (R-3m) - DFT relaxed](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/yti2fe9-r-3m-dft-relaxed) (file, id `1ec18865-6a91-495f-b8d5-277482d1b6a7`)
- [Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 58: Fe/Co site order controls anisotropy in YFe₃Co₂](https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-58-fe-co-site-order-controls-anisotropy-in-yfe3co2) (post, id `01a1f138-069f-7af5-ab2d-0e6b63c1430a`)
- [Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 54: Mn₂FeB₂, a cobalt-free tetragonal boride that reads 1.5–1.8 MJ/m³ at 1.4–1.5 T, three checks still open](https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-54-mn2feb2-a-cobalt-free-tetragonal-boride-that-reads-1-5-1-8-mj-m3-at-1-4-1-5-t-three-checks-still-open) (post, id `01a1f066-218e-7632-83b6-4ef632153e5e`)
