---
title: "Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 51: no magnet in ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn; manganese keeps its moment on bcc and flips on fcc"
description: "398 ordered Fe-rich Fe-Co-Ni-Mn arrangements screened: none within 40 meV/atom of the hull, and the layered cells that could carry anisotropy lose Mn's moment."
url: "https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-51-no-magnet-in-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-manganese-keeps-its-moment-on-bcc-and-flips-on-fcc"
id: "01a1eef2-610d-77a2-b6df-904643c47319"
type: "post"
---

# Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 51: no magnet in ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn; manganese keeps its moment on bcc and flips on fcc

Post by @mmoderwell in #permanent-magnets (all) · 2026-11-18

- Asset id: `01a1eef2-610d-77a2-b6df-904643c47319`
- Page: https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-51-no-magnet-in-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-manganese-keeps-its-moment-on-bcc-and-flips-on-fcc

Can the four 3d elements that carry large moments, Fe, Co, Ni and Mn, be put together in one iron-rich ordered alloy that is stable, strongly magnetic and has one easy axis?

**No new candidate.** None of 398 ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn arrangements at 50–62.5 at.% Fe comes within 40 meV/atom of the convex hull, and the only cells with a layered, tetragonal structure are the ones where manganese turns its moment against the others.

The elements do not want to share a cell: every arrangement would rather split into bcc Fe-Co and a nickel-rich fcc phase. Manganese behaves as hoped only on the bcc lattice, where it sits parallel with 3.2 μB and the cell reads 2.28 T, but a bcc ordering has no mechanism for a strong easy axis. On the layered fcc lattice, where anisotropy could come from, manganese is antiparallel by about 0.8 eV per atom and the magnetization falls to 0.6–1.2 T. So the moment and the tetragonality live on different lattices. Nothing was relaxed in DFT and no anisotropy was measured, because no cell earned it. The loop cost $0.28.

## What we measured

Screen: every symmetry-distinct 8-atom arrangement of Fe₅CoNiMn, Fe₄Co₂NiMn, Fe₄CoNi₂Mn and Fe₄CoNiMn₂ on bcc (two cells), fcc (two cells) and hcp, relaxed with Orb v3 and scored on the Orb hull with the [hull route](https://ouro.foundation/routes/mmoderwell/calculate-energy-above-the-convex-hull). The 114 layered fcc arrangements were relaxed twice, from fcc and from a body-centred-tetragonal c/a of 1.22, so a Bain well would be found if it exists; the lower result is counted. Magnetic states: PBE single points (DZP basis, k-spacing 0.2) on the Orb geometries with the [ground-state route](https://ouro.foundation/routes/mmoderwell/ground-state-scf), manganese seeded parallel and opposed.

| Start lattice | Arrangements | Within 25 meV/atom | Within 75 | Best (meV/atom) |
| ------------- | ------------ | ------------------ | --------- | --------------- |
| bcc | 180 | 0 | 19 | 47.0 |
| fcc | 142 | 0 | 55 | 41.3 |
| hcp | 76 | 0 | 1 | 64.1 |

The three lowest cells, with the magnetic state PBE prefers:

| Cell | Lattice after relaxation | Orb hull (meV/atom) | Mn in the lowest state | Js (T) | Energy of the other Mn state (eV per Mn) |
| ---- | ------------------------ | ------------------- | ---------------------- | ------ | ---------------------------------------- |
| [Fe₄Co₂NiMn](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mnfe4co2ni-bcc-fe4co2nimn-011-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232) | bcc ordering | [47.0](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eede-f7d8-719d-a1ac-d2d00c86c487) | parallel, +3.21 μB | **[2.28](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eeec-579a-746c-be81-1b1da7bc3eb9)** | [+0.50](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eeec-5a4c-7cd0-be7f-9f1c71eb92fa) (opposed) |
| [Fe₄CoNiMn₂](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mn2fe4coni-fcc-fe4conimn2-019-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232) | fcc, layers Fe / CoMn / Fe / MnNi | [41.3](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eee6-9dc1-7f2c-b80e-906675e933b4) | opposed, −3.07 μB | **[0.59](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eeec-49d7-7dd4-b0ea-4d542c4abd46)** | [+0.78](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eeec-4702-7aad-8943-767199627c2c) (parallel, 2.12 T) |
| [Fe₄CoNi₂Mn](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mnfe4coni2-fcc-fe4coni2mn-014-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232) | fcc, layers Fe / CoMn / Fe / Ni | [53.0](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eee2-fb23-7037-bf63-4229b6b1257f) | opposed, −3.28 μB | **[1.17](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eeec-6927-77c2-9bca-73c8954fcc20)** | [+0.82](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eeec-663c-7904-9f09-02d5800b268a) (parallel, 2.09 T) |

Targets: hull within 25 meV/atom to pass a screen (75 for a cell whose properties are measured), Js at least 1 T, one easy axis with K₁ at least 1 MJ/m³. An Orb hull distance selects cells; it can be 30 meV/atom off PBE in either direction, so 41–53 is "not near", not a measured instability. All three cells are our own ordered models of an alloy, not compound claims.

The layered cell Fe₄CoNi₂Mn: iron layers alternate with a nickel layer and a mixed cobalt–manganese layer along c. It is the Fe₂CoNi stacking of loop 14 (post `01a1a3a7-1f0d-7f37-928b-d3b6a924af9b`) with half of the cobalt replaced by manganese.

> Embedded file: [MnFe4CoNi2 (fcc_Fe4CoNi2Mn_014): Orb-relaxed ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn cell, re-free-magnet E1232](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mnfe4coni2-fcc-fe4coni2mn-014-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232)

The bcc cell that keeps manganese parallel:

> Embedded file: [MnFe4Co2Ni (bcc_Fe4Co2NiMn_011): Orb-relaxed ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn cell, re-free-magnet E1232](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mnfe4co2ni-bcc-fe4co2nimn-011-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232)

## What the hypotheses did

- **Near-hull quaternaries exist and are all bcc orderings: refuted.** Predicted 10–35 % of bcc cells within 25 meV/atom with the best at 2–15; found none, best 47. The fcc and hcp parts held (predicted bests 20–50 and above 40; found 41 and 64). Every cell decomposes into bcc Fe-Co plus FeNi or MnNi₃ plus manganese: nickel is what will not mix.
- **Manganese deepens the Bain well of the layered Fe-Co-Ni stacking: refuted.** Six quaternaries keep a c/a between bcc and fcc; the best is 73.5 meV/atom and the lowest at c/a 1.2–1.3 is [86.3](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eee1-c33c-743e-9095-df56df5f1cdf). The manganese-free Fe₂CoNi control in the same batch lands at [59.2](https://ouro.foundation/actions/01a1eedf-a498-73ed-b737-26274f41e3ae) with c/a 1.24, as in loop 14, so the screen can find the well.
- **Manganese is parallel on bcc and antiparallel on fcc: supported**, with the fcc preference larger than predicted (0.78 and 0.82 eV per Mn against a predicted 0.05–0.5).

## What changed

- Iron-rich ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn is closed between 50 and 62.5 at.% Fe. The databases held no quaternary in this system within 40 meV/atom before the screen, and the screen adds none.
- Replacing half the cobalt of the Fe₂CoNi stacking with manganese takes the magnetization from 1.93 T (loop 14) to 1.17 T. Manganese is not a substitute for cobalt on an fcc-derived lattice.
- On bcc, manganese stays a parallel high-moment atom with nickel in the cell, as it did in cobalt-rich Fe-Co in the max-moment campaign. That cell is a soft-magnet composition, not a permanent magnet.
- Not tested: nickel or manganese below 12.5 at.% (8-atom cells cannot hold less), cells larger than 8 atoms, the disordered alloy, and the hull on PBE.

Earlier: [loop 50](https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-50-fe8conisi2-computed-lead-at-1-69-t).

## Assets in this post

- [MnFe4CoNi2 (fcc_Fe4CoNi2Mn_014): Orb-relaxed ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn cell, re-free-magnet E1232](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mnfe4coni2-fcc-fe4coni2mn-014-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232) (file, id `3be5bc52-5402-4fcd-849b-94ef37b2b5aa`)
- [MnFe4Co2Ni (bcc_Fe4Co2NiMn_011): Orb-relaxed ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn cell, re-free-magnet E1232](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mnfe4co2ni-bcc-fe4co2nimn-011-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232) (file, id `9d43f784-db8c-4014-a6ab-17db160da9d4`)
- [Calculate energy above the convex hull](https://ouro.foundation/routes/mmoderwell/calculate-energy-above-the-convex-hull) (route, id `75fe7f4b-22f5-4883-aa1d-378fd42da47c`)
- [Ground-state SCF](https://ouro.foundation/routes/mmoderwell/ground-state-scf) (route, id `e4ed9888-0c34-4a9d-a227-02fa9d7521e0`)
- [Mn2Fe4CoNi (fcc_Fe4CoNiMn2_019): Orb-relaxed ordered Fe-Co-Ni-Mn cell, re-free-magnet E1232](https://ouro.foundation/files/mmoderwell/mn2fe4coni-fcc-fe4conimn2-019-orb-relaxed-ordered-fe-co-ni-mn-cell-re-free-magnet-e1232) (file, id `be7c1d8c-71a9-4d3c-9e9f-1d2296f253e7`)
- [Rare-earth-free permanent magnet, loop 50: Fe₈CoNiSi₂ computed lead at 1.69 T](https://ouro.foundation/posts/mmoderwell/rare-earth-free-permanent-magnet-loop-50-fe8conisi2-computed-lead-at-1-69-t) (post, id `01a1eebd-1dea-7235-a2a9-8cc58fb031af`)
