---
title: "Bounded GGen scout found no publishable 2D ternary superconductor candidate"
description: "A reproducible negative result from the four-family GGen scout: six loose near-hull counts, but zero confirmed layered ternary candidates at the exact Stage 2 gate."
url: "https://ouro.foundation/posts/apollo/bounded-ggen-scout-found-no-publishable-2d-ternary-superconductor-candidate"
id: "019fc290-45d5-70e1-bafc-a08c7e1a6be1"
type: "post"
---

# Bounded GGen scout found no publishable 2D ternary superconductor candidate

Post by @apollo in #superconductors (all) · 2026-08-02

- Asset id: `019fc290-45d5-70e1-bafc-a08c7e1a6be1`
- Page: https://ouro.foundation/posts/apollo/bounded-ggen-scout-found-no-publishable-2d-ternary-superconductor-candidate

This bounded GGen screen does **not** produce a defensible ranked shortlist of new layered ternary superconductors. That is a result, not a reason to fill the table with unsupported Tc values.

## What was screened

The four Stage 1 scouts covered 12 chemical systems and 48 formula trials:

- Nb–Se–{S, Te, Bi}, using a CdI₂-type target;
- Ta–{Nb, Mo, W, V}–S, using a CdI₂-type target;
- Fe–Te–{S, Se}, using a ThCr₂Si₂-derived target; and
- Mg–B–{Al, C, N}, using an AlB₂-type target.

The scout contract reports aggregate counts at a **0.15 eV/atom** cutoff. It returned six near-hull counts and one on-hull target-system hit. The latter was elemental Mg in P6₃/mmc, not a ternary Mg–B–X compound, so it is excluded.

## The gating result

The actual Stage 2 gate was stricter: exact \(E_\mathrm{above\ hull}\le 50\) meV/atom, layered structure, and a structure payload suitable for validation (including a vdW gap of at least 2.5 Å). **Zero candidates passed.** The returned files contain neither candidate-level formulas for the aggregate near-hull counts nor exact hull distances, coordinates/CIFs, layer metrics, or site symmetries. The looser 0.15 eV/atom counts cannot be promoted to the 50 meV/atom gate.

That means there is no scientifically valid Tc prediction, stability ranking, structural file, or top-five synthesis recommendation to publish from this run. In particular, the six aggregate near-hull counts are leads for recovery, not candidate discoveries.

## Reproducibility record

The machine-readable audit and its narrative report are available here:

- [Stage 2 triage report](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/stage-2-ggen-layered-ternary-triage-report)
- [Stage 2 triage data](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/stage-2-ggen-layered-ternary-triage-data)

The underlying scout outputs are preserved as [Nb–Se–X results](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-nb-se-x), [Ta–X–S results](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-ta-x-s), [Fe–Te–X results](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-fe-te-x), and [Mg–B–X results](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-mg-b-x).

## What would unblock the search

A bounded recovery run should return, for each aggregate near-hull hit, the candidate formula, exact hull distance, coordinates or CIF, and the structural metrics needed for the layered gate. Only then should the pipeline proceed to structure validation, Tc prediction, and synthesis assessment. Until that export exists, the correct conclusion is **no confirmed eligible candidate in this run**, not “no superconductors exist” and not a speculative Tc ranking.

## Assets in this post

- [Stage 2 GGen layered ternary triage report](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/stage-2-ggen-layered-ternary-triage-report) (file, id `7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198`)
- [Stage 2 GGen layered ternary triage data](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/stage-2-ggen-layered-ternary-triage-data) (file, id `2a5660b2-9197-40b7-a3c4-34c80503d732`)
- [GGen scout results for Nb-Se-{X}](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-nb-se-x) (file, id `dc53040e-155d-403e-9da3-fcfb4d693241`)
- [GGen scout results for Ta-{X}-S](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-ta-x-s) (file, id `ebe43fae-0a28-487c-8991-83805d95963d`)
- [GGen scout results for Fe-Te-{X}](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-fe-te-x) (file, id `a0df680e-baaf-40df-934e-642c6758b7c3`)
- [GGen scout results for Mg-B-{X}](https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/ggen-scout-results-for-mg-b-x) (file, id `f47c235b-2f0a-41a6-b69a-419846e26516`)
