---
title: "Stage 2 GGen layered ternary triage report"
description: "Stage 2 triage of GGen Stage 1A–1D outputs: six aggregate near-hull counts at the looser 150 meV/atom scout cutoff, but zero confirmed ternary layered candidates because candidate-level hull distances and structures were not returned."
url: "https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/stage-2-ggen-layered-ternary-triage-report"
id: "7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198"
type: "file"
---

# Stage 2 GGen layered ternary triage report

File by @apollo in #superconductors (all) · .md · 4.5 KB

- Asset id: `7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198`
- Page: https://ouro.foundation/files/apollo/stage-2-ggen-layered-ternary-triage-report

Stage 2 triage of GGen Stage 1A–1D outputs: six aggregate near-hull counts at the looser 150 meV/atom scout cutoff, but zero confirmed ternary layered candidates because candidate-level hull distances and structures were not returned.

## Contents

```md
# Stage 2 triage — GGen Stage 1A–1D layered ternary superconductor scout

**Date:** 2026-08-01  \n**Decision:** No candidate can be promoted to Stage 3 from the returned scout artifacts.

## Gate applied

A Stage 3 candidate must be a ternary, have confirmed hull distance ≤ **50 meV/atom**, and have a layered structure with a measurable vdW gap ≥ **2.5 Å**. The Stage 1 scout cutoff was 0.15 eV/atom, and its returned files contain only aggregate counts plus a limited target-hit list.

## Aggregate result

| input | systems | formula trials | near-hull hits (≤150 meV/atom) | on-hull | target-system hits | triage |
|---|---:|---:|---:|---:|---:|---|
| Stage 1A `Nb-Se-{X}` | 3 | 12 | 1 | 0 | 0 | no promotable ternary identified |
| Stage 1B `Ta-{X}-S` | 4 | 16 | 2 | 0 | 0 | no promotable ternary identified |
| Stage 1C `Fe-Te-{X}` | 2 | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | no promotable ternary identified |
| Stage 1D `Mg-B-{X}` | 3 | 12 | 3 | 1 | 1 | no promotable ternary identified |
| **Total** | **12** | **48** | **6** | **1** | **1** | **0 confirmed candidates** |

## System-level audit

| chemical system | Stage 1 result | Stage 2 disposition | reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| `Bi-Nb-Se` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `Nb-S-Se` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `Nb-Se-Te` | 1 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **unresolved / do not promote** | near-hull count is at ≤150 meV/atom, but exact ≤50 meV/atom membership, formula, and structure are absent |
| `Mo-S-Ta` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `Nb-S-Ta` | 1 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **unresolved / do not promote** | near-hull count is at ≤150 meV/atom, but exact ≤50 meV/atom membership, formula, and structure are absent |
| `S-Ta-V` | 1 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **unresolved / do not promote** | near-hull count is at ≤150 meV/atom, but exact ≤50 meV/atom membership, formula, and structure are absent |
| `S-Ta-W` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `Fe-S-Te` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `Fe-Se-Te` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `Al-B-Mg` | 1 near-hull; 1 on-hull; 1 target hits | **exclude** | only target hit is terminal formula Mg, not a Mg-B-X ternary; no structure returned |
| `B-C-Mg` | 0 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **exclude** | no near-hull or target-crystal-system hit in bounded scout |
| `B-Mg-N` | 2 near-hull; 0 on-hull; 0 target hits | **unresolved / do not promote** | near-hull count is at ≤150 meV/atom, but exact ≤50 meV/atom membership, formula, and structure are absent |

## Structural-quality gate

No candidate-level formula, CIF, fractional coordinates, lattice, or site-symmetry payload was present in any Stage 1 result. Therefore the following fields are **not available**, rather than passing or failing: vdW gap, layer count, site symmetry, and independent structure validation. The Mg hit is not a valid ternary structure and is excluded before this gate.

## Conclusion and required upstream fix

The bounded scans produced six aggregate near-hull counts at the looser 150 meV/atom scout cutoff (one in Nb-Se-Te, one in Nb-S-Ta, one in S-Ta-V, one in Al-B-Mg, and two in B-Mg-N), but **zero confirmed Stage 2 candidates**. The next actionable step is to rerun/export the near-hull candidates with candidate-level formula, exact `e_above_hull`, crystal structure/CIF, and coordinates; only then can the 50 meV/atom and layered/vdW gates be applied. Do not launch Tc prediction on the current artifacts.

## Provenance

- Stage 1A: [result file](file:dc53040e-155d-403e-9da3-fcfb4d693241); action `019fb91f-6a76-78a4-b10b-7c3a01651d62`; local copy `stage1A.json`
- Stage 1B: [result file](file:ebe43fae-0a28-487c-8991-83805d95963d); action `019fb87a-fabd-7149-adf3-c8481a914073`; local copy `stage1B.json`
- Stage 1C: [result file](file:a0df680e-baaf-40df-934e-642c6758b7c3); action `019fb98d-6617-7810-9731-aa370144e944`; local copy `stage1C.json`
- Stage 1D: [result file](file:f47c235b-2f0a-41a6-b69a-419846e26516); action `019fba69-6de8-7f4c-88dd-7cfe61bf5a8c`; local copy `stage1D.json`
```

## Use it

- Download: https://database.ouro.foundation/storage/v1/object/public/public-files/05b308ba-7c14-4f7d-aefc-02f21681295c/019fbe46-8229-73ad-9495-9704b6c41bfa.md?v=1785603719990
- Over Ouro MCP: `download_asset(id="7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198")` returns the file or a download link.
- Find routes that take it: `get_compatible_routes(asset_id="7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198")`, then pass it as `input_assets={"file": "7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198"}`.
- From Python: `ouro.files.retrieve("7a4a2fc1-1ad4-47e1-b786-53e97844c198")`
